I recently read this article on Salon.com where the author essentially argues that canning food is expensive; it's not en vogue because of the economic downturn, it's merely one in a long line of expensive (female) hobbies disseminated by "foodie propaganda." And by the way, sucka, the people who've been feeding you this uber-hip trend? They're professionals — they're making money off their canned food. You're just buying it.
To be fair, the author, Sarah Karnasiewicz, is not being a jerk. The article was well-thought out. And I agree with large parts of it. But it's not the whole story. (And as a woman, I find it fascinating that 'female' hobbies are trivialized based on expense. No one looks down their noses at men for playing golf. After all, it's far more expensive, and these men they are emulating are PROFESSIONAL golfers. They actually MAKE MONEY from this. And You, Sir, Are No Tiger Woods!) – and thank goodness on that last part.
So before we all go off dismissing canning and preserving as some sort of cutesy hobby that allows women to serve fancy jam-laden desserts at hipster cocktail parties, I'd like to briefly explain why I've personally gotten into canning.
In 2006, my canning adventures began, thanks to a garden with too many tomato plants. My husband made a big deal about the fact that I had planted way too many tomato plants. I was intent on proving him wrong. I had planted just the right amount of tomato plants…as long as I was planning on canning a year's worth of pasta sauce and salsa. Maybe some chutney as well. And some barbecue sauce. And sweet and sour. Yes…the perfect amount of tomato plants.
I did a fair amount of research that summer, preparing for the August harvest. I was pretty proud of what I had accomplished. I had never known a single person who had canned their own food (I might have known people, but certainly didn't experience them as food canners). I was born and raised in Silicon Valley. My grandparents were from Los Angeles. We don't do a lot of canning 'round these parts (at least not these days).
This was my very own accomplishment. I had discovered something, made something. Something valuable. I felt like Christopher Columbus and the Native Americans all rolled into one.
The following April I was listening to NPR. Barbara Kingsolver was being interviewed about her soon-to-be-released book, Animal, Vegetable, Miracle: A Year of Food Life. The idea of being self-sufficient had been growing in me for a number of years. The soil in the Bay Area is amazing. I felt a loss of what used to be a valley filled with orchards, farmers and a vibrant canning industry.
My views are occasionally pessimistic: I worried about the ramifications of large population increases, soil contaminated by pesticides and chemicals, and a generation of people no longer aware of how to care for themselves should everything not be available to them at the corner store.
Within worry is always hidden opportunity. For me, this was an opportunity to learn something valuable that would allow me to feel the weight of my own power. We are all creators and I was gonna create me some food!
I bought Barbara Kingsolver's book and relished in the opportunity to attempt my own urban homestead, in my own small way. I don't have a specific end goal, though my best friend and I always talk about the Holy Grail of owning our own goats and chickens. For now, I am focusing on seeing how much of my food I can grow and preserve throughout the year, for the least possible cost.
I don't do this to be cute, though my husband really thinks I do look very cute in this apron:
I actually do this because I want to be able to teach my children something that will always be of value to them. And I want them to respect food. I want them to know where it comes from and I want the proper foods to be nourishing their bodies. I want them to respect the very hard work that farmers perform and the immense value that provides all of us.
I want to imagine that when I am gone, my children and grandchildren and great-great grandchildren will talk about "the family recipe" for the perfect marinara.
I am Italian after all, I should know this shit.
As the author of the Salon.com article pointed out, I too have made ridiculously expensive canned food. But for the most part, I spend less than I would if I were buying it from a store. In general, I am a very practical gal.
This recipe is a perfect representation of that. The Tigress Can Jam ingredient of the month is the ever-so-sweet BERRY.
If I was being hip, I would have made olallieberry and thyme cordials. That's what I wanted to make. I actually still intend to at some point because my God, mixed with some vodka or chambord – oh my.
Instead I was immensely practical. I have a lemon tree and am always looking for ways to put it to use. I have a CSA that's currently giving me 8 baskets of strawberries a week. I have two kids and a plethora of neighbors' kids who spent time at my house. Put them together and what do you get?
Strawberry Lemonade Concentrate!
This recipe is adapted from Ball's Complete Book of Home Preserving and makes approximately 3 quarts of canned concentrate with enough left over for a fresh glass for yourself. Just add ice.
6 cups strawberries, cleaned and hulled
4 cups freshly squeezed lemon juice
6 cups sugar
In a food processor (or blender) puree strawberries in batches.
Transfer strawberry puree to a stainless steel saucepan over medium-high heat. DO NOT BOIL. Add lemon juice and sugar and stir to combine.
Using a candy thermometer to measure (dip it halfway in the mixture and don't let it touch the pan) heat to 190 degrees Fahrenheit. Test it every few minutes, it will get there quickly. Remove from heat.
Ladle mixture into jars leaving 1/4 inch headspace. Wipe rim, center lid on jar and add screw band.
Place jars in canner. Jars should be covered by an inch of water. Bring to a boil and process for 15 minutes.
Don't forget to put the lid on!
Remove lid after processing and let jars sit for 5 minutes before removing.
Remove jars, cool and store. The voila! picture is at the top of the article, of course. Go take a look at it again. Purdy, huh?
When you're ready to use your concentrate, pour it in a pitcher, fill the quart jar with water and add that to the pitcher as well. Test the strawberry lemonade and if it's thicker than you prefer, you can add additional water 1/4 cup at a time until you reach your preferred balance.
This strawberry lemonade is amazingly good. And imagine how happy it will make you in the middle of winter when fresh strawberries and lemons are no where in sight. And because of what I pay for my CSA, the fact that I grow my own strawberries as well, have a lemon tree, and buy my organic sugar in bulk from bins – I figured the cost of this to run around $1 – $1.25 for a pitcher. And it's super quick to make.
So, I guess what I am trying to say is this: stick it, Salon.com.









{ 23 comments… read them below or add one }
Great info! I love to can the product of my garden. Last year tomato worms ate the tops of my tomato plants off and the tomatoes all ripened at once. If I didn’t know how to can already, I would have learned quickly or lost most of that lovely crop. I made sweet chili sauce, my Mom’s favorite, and salsa. Spooning it over hot mac & cheese on a winter’s evening is so satisfying! Goes to show that everything printed isn’t gospel. So there Salon.com! Must go get lemons….Michigan strawberries are in season up the road and raspberries will be in soon….wonder how that would taste?
Thanks, I enjoyed your entry and the recipe. Not so much the Salon.com article! What the Salon author also get is that its a way to use SURPLUS produce… eat and enjoy as much as you can while its fresh and cheap. Any EXTRA gets preserved for a time when one cant get fresh, or fresh is way more expensive. An urban gardener probably doesnt get enough surplus to do much canning, or if so, small batch only. But for those that are part of CSA or other direct access to large quantity of fresh food in season, it is a natural extension of farm-to-table/knowing whats in the food we eat. Why anyone would be so foolish as to spend $16 on two quarts of strawberries and then choose to not gobble them up while at their peak is astounding to me. Its the 12th quart of strawberries, when the price is down to a fraction and you cant possibly eat another one, that is one you start canning. Or the fig tree in the yard, (or mango, or apple or whatever it is where you live)– when its dropping the fruit and the choice is for it to continue denting your car or harvest and use whats readily available. The let-them-eat-cake attitude the Salon author is simply lazy journalism.
i read the Salon.com article and now have a zillion more white hairs and my blood pressure has bubbled over… guess i’d be an ‘elitist’ considering i’ve been canning and preserving since i was 13! amazing skills which my mother taught me and i’ve continued and honed for the past 45 plus years… your recipe sounds delightful and i’m going to give it a go! thanks for a great article…
I have just read the salon.com article 2 times to make sure I am understanding her. I am completely fired up over it. HOBBYIST!? Really?! Thank you for the link and for your post. The author on salon.com just doesn’t get it and should not trivialize something that has been done for years and years. Our society is brainwashed to think that we cannot provide for ourselves that someone else knows more. How can some stranger in a factory 500 miles or more away know more about feeding my family than me? And what about your carbon footprint Miss Salon.com? Yes, Smuckers is cheaper but I don’t think in the long run and in the big picture it is better. Some factory has to be turned on with some type of power, then it is put into new containers, then put on a truck and shipped to the grocery, then you drive it from the grocery to your house and finally the jar ends up in the landfill or in recycling bin which gets driven again to the recyling plant which is using some type of power to turn your jar into something else. Whew. I have worn myself out with this article. LOL! Thanks again. And thank you for canning!
Ladies, you are all awesome! And I am so glad to see others felt the same as I did. I think it’s so funny how people make it sound like “rganic food” is elite — and now THIS. Canned Food is ELITE! Really? I bet all of those farmers in middle America are happy to hear they’ve finally reached Elite Status!
As for me? I live in the middle of Silicon Valley. I still have a lemon tree, lime, tangerine, persimmon, apple, cherry, grape vine, 3 blueberry bushes and tons of strawberries! What do I do if not can? Let it all go to waste? Hmmmm…sounds pretty elite to me!
Love your site and love this post
I, too, live in Silicon Valley. When we moved to our house 20 years ago we had maybe three fruit trees; now we have 20. There is nothing more satisfying than putting up fruits and veggies you’ve grown yourself. And your family can eat like kings all winter long from the produce you preserve. Keep up the great work! I’m glad to have found your site.
Paige- I have a recipe in an old canning cookbook that explains how to make your own pectin with lemons and apples. If you are interested I can send it to you. Its lengthy or I would just do it now;)
Yes, Brenna, please send it to me! That would be awesome! Send to: paige@canningwithkids.com
Thank you!!!
Love this post Paige. So well put! And I just HAVE to try this recipe… looking forward to it!
Glad you saw it, Emily! Yes, make the it and let me know how you like it. It’s getting rave reviews over here!
Holy smokes … I’ve been fretting about what kind of fruity drink to make for us girls on the 4th as I’m getting tired of the same old stuff. I think I’ve found the answer right here! I’m not going to bother canning this stuff; just going to add some vodka, some sparking water (or lemon-lime soda) and call it good.
Thanks for the inspiration! I’m having tons of fun peeking around on your site. It’s lovely.
Nic – I am using this recipe for the same purpose for our 4th of July charades!
I’m actually making 3 more quarts today because I’ve been going through them so quickly, and I got a ton more strawberries from my CSA and my garden this week. YIPPEE!
And thank you for the nice words on my blog.
Paige – Nice work! And thanks for pointing out that article, I hadn’t seen it. That’s the second one that Salon.com has printed. They just love being snarky, don’t they?
Any idea if this recipe would work with blueberries instead of strawberries?
@Julie – YES! They do!
@Kay – Omigosh that sounds delicious! And I happen to have maybe 6 cups of blueberries needing to be used! Should I?!?!? Could I?!?!?!
Great post Paige! Your canned strawberry lemon concentrate sounds delicious. Thanks for pointing out that article.
I planted way too many tomato plants this year (or so it might seem) but I’m going to have fun canning them.
I can to save money and believe me when I say this, it not only saves me money, it makes it possible for me to make the things my family enjoys without the extra sugar and salt.
Now your strawberry lemonade concentrate sounds amazing, I will have to try it when Oregon Strawberries come into season this year.. I am part of a group of gleaners and will add this to my list of recipes to saw with the group, what a great way to make something my kids love and have one had through out the year.
I made your strawberry lemonade this year and it was amazing! I also canned what we did not drink, well I just opened a can and for some reason it was really bitter after being on the shelf for only about two months. Do you know what I could have done wrong?
hmmm…bitter? Like how? The one thing I would say is that if something tastes off, don’t have it. Botulism (the thing we worry about with canning) has no taste. And this recipe is way too acidic and sugary to worry about that. Mold would be your biggest problem and could have occurred if you didn’t properly seal it. Was the seal easy to remove? Other than that, I will say that with my regular lemonade concentrate I have had this happen before and it was because essentially I didn’t mix well enough so maybe a few jars seemed to have less sugar than the rest. It might be that.
I just made this tonight and they taste great. I keep having an issue with strawberries, though, this recipe included. They don’t look that pretty in the jars several hours later. The liquid has separated. I’m sure it will taste fine, but I don’t get what i”m doing wrong. Used the same quantities but doubled the recipe; did water bath for 15.
Mine comes out so red. Usually no separation. In fact I just ran to my basement to check the batch I canned a month ago. hmmmm…Yes, it will be fine, though.
Do you think this recipe would work with bottled lemon or lime juice? Also…has anyone tried a sugar substitute? If so…what kind?
Yes it would work with bottled lemon juice. Havent tried the sugar substitute but it would mold in the jar without the sugar, potentially.